Friday, October 8, 2010

The Toulmin Model

I have been having trouble with my very old bike that I use to get to class for a while now. The latest problem to happen was that the brakes started to work poorly. I once measured the stopping distance, and it was about 30ft to go from about 10mph down to 0. This is kind of scary because if I need to stop suddenly it's not going to happen. So I decided this needed to be fixed.

My claim was that my brakes needed to be fixed, and soon on the grounds that 30ft is not a safe stopping distance if i need to stop quickly. The warrant would be that I can think of many situations where 30ft of stopping distance is took much. If a person walks in front of me and I'm going fast, I won't be able to stop in time. The backing would be that the previous 'what if' statement is not a hypothetical. I know it's valid because it has already happened once. The qualification would be sometimes. Not every time I need to stop, will I need to stop on a dime; but there are occasions when I will need to stop suddenly.

I fixed my brakes today and almost rolled forward off my bike because they work so well now. Hopefully I won't be having anymore collisions or near misses any time soon.

-Matt

3 comments:

  1. Matt,

    Nice job connecting a great example to the Toulmin Model. My bike is pretty beat up as well, I'm just too lazy to actually work up the effort to fix it. Most of the time I just hope and pray that the pedestrians aren't stupid enough to walk into a street without looking both ways first. Good Work!

    Alex

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well, make sure that you get used to the fixed brakes, because you don't want to be in that "broken brakes" mindset, or else, you'll jam on them, and FLY OUT OF THE BIKE! Yea, it hurts. This was definitely a really good application of the Toulmin Model, and I can definitely see that you have applied it appropriately towards all the parts. One thing is, how did you figure out that it was specifically the breaks and nothing else (like the chain)?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think you did a great job using the Toulmin Model to justify and solve the problem you were having with your bike. Your claim was explained and justified and you used your conclusion to take action. You also took an interesting stance on your qualifier. Good job again and I'm glad you got it fixed, 30ft is a long way to go!

    ReplyDelete